Made by: Nyperold
The alien that replaces Jon here is a Mook from the Mother video game series. It's most likely intended to reference EarthBound, the second game in the series and (for a long time) the only one officially released in the West. The choice of a Mook was inspired by Garfield's line "Mon't mook at meef.", but as a happy coincidence, certain varieties of Mooks can drop PSI Caramels, making them a perfect fit for a comic concerning caramels.
Original strip: 1981-11-11.
Clay Mook from the Earthbound (Mother) series, from the Nintendo Wiki.
Mook: Oh, Garfield Mook: What happened to my candy caramels? Garfield: Mon't mook at meef.